All products are independently selected by our editors. If you buy something, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn More >
Mushroom coffee has exploded in popularity as a healthier, more balanced alternative to traditional coffee. With promises of sustained energy, sharper focus, and gut health benefits, it’s no wonder more people are making the switch.
But with so many brands on the market, which one is actually worth your time (and money)?
We tested and researched five of the top mushroom coffee brands to see how they compare. Each was evaluated on taste, ingredient quality, effectiveness, and overall value.
Whether you’re looking for better focus, more energy, or a smoother coffee experience without jitters, here’s how these mushroom coffees stack up.
You’re going to love these!
1. Neubrain – The Best Overall Mushroom Coffee
Why We Ranked It #1:
Neubrain takes mushroom coffee to the next level by combining real coffee with functional mushrooms and scientifically backed nootropics.
While other brands focus purely on adaptogens, Neubrain includes CognatiQ®, Alpha GPC, and Infinergy® to deliver long-lasting energy, improved mental clarity, and enhanced focus without the jitters or crash.
We also loved that Neubrain tastes exactly like traditional coffee, unlike some competitors that have a strong earthy or bitter flavor. If you’re looking for a smarter way to start your day, this is the ultimate pick.
👉 Best for: High achievers, busy professionals, and anyone looking for a brain-boosting coffee upgrade.
Pros
- Tastes exactly like real coffee (no earthy or bitter aftertaste).
- 5 Functional Mushrooms: Lion’s Mane, Chaga, Cordyceps, Reishi, Turkey Tail.
- Patented Nootropics: CognatiQ®, Infinergy®, Alpha GPC, L-Tyrosine, L-Theanine.
- 100% Fruiting Body Mushrooms (No fillers or mycelium).
- Supports brain function, sustained energy, and gut health.
- Collagen for hair, skin, and nails.
- Subscription Model but is Easy To Cancel.
- Money-back guarantee.
Cons
- Only available online.
- No decaf version yet.
2. Four Sigmatic – Great for Adaptogenic Support
Why We Ranked It #2:
Four Sigmatic is one of the most well-known mushroom coffee brands, and for good reason. Their blends include Lion’s Mane, Chaga, and Reishi to support brain function and immune health.
However, compared to Neubrain, Four Sigmatic lacks nootropics and additional focus enhancers, making it less effective for cognitive performance.
👉 Best for: Those looking for a high-quality, organic mushroom coffee with strong adaptogenic benefits.
Pros
- Uses organic fruiting body mushrooms.
- Multiple formats: Ground coffee, instant, and whole bean.
- Available in certain grocery stores.
Cons
- Strong mushroom taste (earthy and bold).
- Expensive ($1.58 per serving, plus shipping).
3. Ryze – A Decent Budget-Friendly Option
Why We Ranked It #3:
Ryze is a decent entry point into mushroom coffee but comes with some trade-offs. While it includes six mushrooms, the dosages are unclear, and some users felt little to no noticeable benefits.
Additionally, the taste is very earthy, which may not appeal to those looking for a more traditional coffee flavor.
👉 Best for: Budget-conscious buyers who don’t mind a strong mushroom taste.
Pros
- Affordable ($1.50 per serving).
- Contains 6 functional mushrooms.
- Pre-mixed with a dairy-free creamer for a smoother taste.
Cons
- Very strong mushroom taste (many describe it as “earthy” or “dirt-like”).
- Subscription model required (though you can cancel anytime).
- Low dosages of each mushroom (unclear effectiveness).
4. Everyday Dose – The Best for Creamy Texture
Why We Ranked It #4:
Everyday Dose is unique because it includes collagen, making it creamier than other mushroom coffees.
However, the serving size is misleading, and many customers find themselves going through the product faster than expected, making it more expensive than advertised.
👉 Best for: Those looking for a creamier mushroom coffee and added collagen benefits.
Pros
- Creamy texture from added collagen.
- No gritty residue or separation.
- Smoother taste than Ryze or Four Sigmatic.
Cons
- Collagen flavor is strong (some users found it overpowering) .
- Only contains 2 mushrooms and lacks additional focus ingredients.
- Same price as Ryze ($1.50 per serving).
- Subscription model is tricky to cancel.
5. Mud/Wtr – The Best for Caffeine-Free Mornings
Why We Ranked It #5:
Mud/Wtr is great if you want to cut caffeine completely, but for those looking for an actual coffee replacement, it falls short.
The taste is bland, the texture is gritty, and it requires additional ingredients to make it enjoyable.
👉 Best for: Those eliminating caffeine entirely who don’t mind a chai-like taste.
Pros
- Almost zero caffeine (great for caffeine-sensitive individuals).
- Includes turmeric and cinnamon for anti-inflammatory benefits.
- Socially conscious brand (donates to mental health causes).
Cons
- Tastes bitter and watery unless you add creamer.
- Does not mix well (often gritty at the bottom of the cup).
- Expensive ($1.67 per serving).
Final Verdict: Which One of These Mushroom Coffees Is Best for You?
- Best Overall: Neubrain: Superior taste, real coffee, brain-boosting nootropics
- Best for Creamy Texture: Everyday Dose – Smoothest, but expensive
- Best for No Caffeine: Mud/Wtr – Low caffeine, but lacks coffee satisfaction
If you want a mushroom coffee that actually tastes like coffee, fuels your brain, and keeps you energized all day, Neubrain is the clear winner.
Mushroom coffee isn’t just a trend – it’s a smarter way to enjoy your daily brew. Whether you’re after better focus, lasting energy, or a smoother cup without the jitters, there’s an option for you.
Neubrain takes the top spot with its unbeatable taste and brain-boosting formula, while Four Sigmatic and Ryze offer solid alternatives for adaptogenic support and budget-conscious buyers.
If you prefer a creamier texture, Everyday Dose might be your pick, and for those ditching caffeine, Mud/Wtr has you covered.
At the end of the day, the best mushroom coffee is the one that fits your taste and lifestyle.
Ready to upgrade your morning routine? Give one a try and see the difference for yourself!
Mark has over 20 years of experience in the catering and hospitality sector. He takes his years of knowledge and expertise and applies it to critiquing coffee equipment and brewing gear.
Since the creation of the Bean Ground coffee blog in 2014, Mark Morphew and a small circle of coffee hobbyists have rigorously tested, reviewed, and researched coffee gear. In most cases, they have purchased the items themselves with the sole intention of rating and evaluating.
In that time, they have built up a list of quality points to look for and what makes specific equipment better than others. They cut through the noise and marketing hype that often surrounds products to give you their unbiased opinions so you can make clear decisions on your next purchase.
